D) Dialectical Presentation - Assignment 4: Notes on the Viewpoints

Power Notes: Viewpoint Analysis

Power Notes are a way to provide ideas and their supporting details, in order to make writing and compiling information, organized and easy to visualize.

Power 1: these are the main ideas, your headings (the description of your viewpoints).

Power 2: these are the reasons that support your main idea (details and reasons for power 1s)

Power 3: these are the details that describe why the reason is provided for the main idea (details, examples and elaboration).

Power 4: sometimes these can be direct quotes that you are wanting to use to support a detail in Power 3.

So for example, if you were conducting research on whether Canada should continue to have the monarchy as our head of state, your power notes may look like:

1. Viewpoint A: Keep the Monarchy

.....2. Don’t mess with tradition
..........3. Keep everything the same (conservative ideology)
..........3. Royal assent on a bill is in the Constitution
.....2. Canada will remain a part of the commonwealth
..........3. Allies with Australia, UK, etc.
.....2. She has no power anyway
..........3. Why worry about it?

1. Viewpoint B: Remove the Monarchy from Canada’s political structure

.....2. Costs too much money
..........3. Approximately $$ goes into funding/hosting/security for the monarchy when they visit Canada
..........3. Wealthy land owners that don’t share
         2. Doesn’t provide any real power
..........3. Royal assent on a bill doesn’t mean much (since the queen doesn’t actually do it herself anyway)
...............4. Book - Real Cost of the Monarchy,  page 8
.....2. Colonialism is a thing of the past
..........3. We are not a “people to be ruled” any longer, we are our own country
..........3. Colonialism only further subjugates the people, leading to feelings of oppression and causing revolutions
...............4. Web source - www.monarchysucks.com, ¶7